Sunni's Contradiction!---Searching for "Words of Rasool" who they claim could not read and write!!!
Salam and Peace, everyone!
I had a long discussion with a brother on youtube.
He insisted that according to a Verse (29:48), the Prophet was illeterate and could not read or write.
Then he said that Al-Quran is Allah's Word, but where will I find the Prophet's words to obey him.
----"where can I find the " words " and teachings of rasool s.a.w. where I can obey and follow ?-----
===================================================================
Please read the following answer. It may interest you.
===================================================================
Dear brother Salam and Peace on you!
Allah knows best what is in our hearts.
On one hand you claim that your Prophet was illiterate,---and on the other hand you wish to find an "illiterate Prophet's" words.
So very strange, very very strange,----how can you find the words of a Prophet who can neither read nor write.
My respected brother, and all the Sunni brothers!---Didn't you all get the news from Imam Bukhari that the person whom you accept as your Prophet, was unable to read and write???
Words???-----from someone who can not write.
I am still wondering at this intellectual demand.
Allah has made it clear in His Exalted Quran that people worship and serve different rubbs or Ilah. Read the link below, if you please:
Who is your rubb?
http://free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9602185.0
According to Al-Quran, people worship different Ilah.
So I believe people have different Prophets, people have different qurans, people believe in different Judgement Days.
For example, some people take a Rubb as their Ilah who has sent down a deffective quran, which is incomplete and unpracticeable without the man-made books of ahadith, Sahih Al-Bukhari, etc.
But I accept The Supreme Being as my Ilah, Who has sent down A Quran which is Perfect and Fully Detailed and does not need any man-made books of ahadith for its explanation.
This is my Iman in my Allah.
Do you have any objection?
-----It means your Ilah is different from my Ilah.
Another example, the person whom you accept as your Prophet, was an illiterate person.
But the person whom I accept as my Prophet, was a literate person.
It means your Prophet is different from my Prophet.
I accept Allah's Quran as The Complete Book of Guidance which is Fully Detailed and does not need any extra explanations.
But you take a group of books as books of guidance, one from Allah and the other from different Imams.
1)-----Brother, Allah commands the momineen in His Exalted Quran:
-----"So do not obey the rejectors and do Jihadan Kabeera (Great Jihad) against them with This (Quran)" (Al Furqaan-52)
In the above Verse, Allah has commanded us to do The Great Jihaad against the kuffaar, with Quran in our hands as the weapon.
It means we have to call the kuffaar of the world to Allah's Quran. That's it.
Whereas the present ummah who follow Al-Bukhari, believe that they should wage a war against the kuffaar to spread Islam.
Brother, how can I go against my Allah when He orders me to do Great Jihaad with Al-Quran in our hands?---How can I kill the non-muslims to spread Islam?
The very meaning of Isalm is to Submit yourself before Allah,----and Salam, Peace, Security.
How can I call the kuffaar to Peace, Salam by waging a war against them and killing and destroyiing them?
Brother, I can not do war, I will only call the kuffaar to Allah.
This is my Iman in my Allah.
2)-----Allah in His Exalted Quran declares that if anyone wants to go out of Islam and become a kafir again, He have no objection in this worldly life. He will question him on The Judgement Day. In this worldly life, Allah Wills to give him a chance before his last breath to return back to Islam.
But Imam Bukhari claims that the Prophet ordered to kill the apostate (Murtad). And whole of the Ummah today have Iman in Imam Bukhari, and not in Allah.
Brother, I will never kill a murtad, at all.
How can I become an enemy of my Allah, and go against His clear-cut Judgement that He Wills to give the murtad a chance to return to Islam.
3)-----The person who commits blasphemy against the Prophet, Allah advices the Prophet to keep patience, and promises that He Himself will look into the affair.
But Imam Bukhari claims that the Prophet ordered to kill the blasphemer.
Brother, I can never go against my Allah's advice, and I would never kill a blasphemer.
I will only try to convince him of Islam. Maybe he will weep, repent and ask Allah's Forgiveness.
This is my Iman in Allah.
Allah declares in His Exalted Quran that there will be no Shafa'ut for the criminals and sinners.
But-----Imam Bukhari claims that the Prophet declares that he will do Shafa'ut for the sinners of his ummah and save them from hellfire.
Brother, I can never have Iman in such a fabricated story of Shafa'ut from the Prophet.
More according to Allah's Quran:
I will never stone the zani to death. Because my Allah never commands us to do so.
I will never degrade womn and take her second in grade with respect to men. Because my Allah never says so.
I will never accept Isa the Messenger alive and returning back to earth. Because my Allah never says so.
-----and so on and on and on-------
Brother this is my Iman in Allah that I find no one in between me and my Allah. No Imam Bukhari, no names of Sahaba, no suffees, no scholars, no mufassir, etc.
Brother, it very clearly means that you worship and serve your Allah,---and I worship and serve my Allah.
And you obey your Prophet,---and I obey my Prophet.
And you follow your Allah's Quran,---and I follow my Allah's Quran.
And a very important point in all this is,---that we two differ with each other.
So, it is very very clear, like daylight, that our Ilah, our Prophets, our Qurans, and our Judgement Days,----are different from each other.
=====================================
One more point is that it is the Ulama Karam of this ummah who have fabricated all these non-Quranic philosophies.
In all times, whenever Allah sent His Messengers, these were the misguided Ulama Karam of the people who always opposed the Messengers.
The unjust rulers of all times persecuted their people, and the misguided ulama always supported those cruel rulers, and they all fought the Messengers of Allah.
Allah annihilated those rulers, ulama and the stubborn people who followed them.
Even today, the Salafee Ulama will invite you to become a Salafee.---The Sunni Ulama will try to make you a Sunni. The Shia Ulama will make you a Shia.
But Allah Wills to make you a momin and a muslim.
So, be warned!
The so-called ahadith in Sahih Al-Bukhari and the likes, in which you have Iman,---you never heard with your own ears the Prophet saying all this.
This is one of the Ulama Karam, Mr. Imam Bukhari who claims that the Prophet said all this.
Brother!---Please don't be angry.
I am not your enemy. And you are not my enemy.
I just put my views before you.
I have Iman that my Allah is Perfect, and His Holy and Exalted Book is Perfect, Complete and Fully Detailed.
It is the ummah's own stubbornness and blindness, that they can't find what Allah is giving them in His Easy-to-understand Book of Hidayah.
What is Iman in Allah?
Iman in Allah is the trust in Allah. Full confidence in Allah---that only Allah is our everything.
There is no partner of Allah.---So, there is no partner of Allah's Quran.
=================================================
Don't say people don't understand.-----People understand everything, at least, when Allah's Revealed Truth is put before them.
Yet, even after understanding Allah's Verses well, they find it difficult to accept The Truth, The Only Truth in the universe.---Why?
Just close your eyes, and peep into your heart. You will find the criminal there.
-----The "Ego".-----Kick him out!
Salam and Peace, everyone!
I had a long discussion with a brother on youtube.
He insisted that according to a Verse (29:48), the Prophet was illeterate and could not read or write.
Then he said that Al-Quran is Allah's Word, but where will I find the Prophet's words to obey him.
----"where can I find the " words " and teachings of rasool s.a.w. where I can obey and follow ?-----
===================================================================
Please read the following answer. It may interest you.
===================================================================
Dear brother Salam and Peace on you!
Allah knows best what is in our hearts.
On one hand you claim that your Prophet was illiterate,---and on the other hand you wish to find an "illiterate Prophet's" words.
So very strange, very very strange,----how can you find the words of a Prophet who can neither read nor write.
My respected brother, and all the Sunni brothers!---Didn't you all get the news from Imam Bukhari that the person whom you accept as your Prophet, was unable to read and write???
Words???-----from someone who can not write.
I am still wondering at this intellectual demand.
Allah has made it clear in His Exalted Quran that people worship and serve different rubbs or Ilah. Read the link below, if you please:
Who is your rubb?
http://free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9602185.0
According to Al-Quran, people worship different Ilah.
So I believe people have different Prophets, people have different qurans, people believe in different Judgement Days.
For example, some people take a Rubb as their Ilah who has sent down a deffective quran, which is incomplete and unpracticeable without the man-made books of ahadith, Sahih Al-Bukhari, etc.
But I accept The Supreme Being as my Ilah, Who has sent down A Quran which is Perfect and Fully Detailed and does not need any man-made books of ahadith for its explanation.
This is my Iman in my Allah.
Do you have any objection?
-----It means your Ilah is different from my Ilah.
Another example, the person whom you accept as your Prophet, was an illiterate person.
But the person whom I accept as my Prophet, was a literate person.
It means your Prophet is different from my Prophet.
I accept Allah's Quran as The Complete Book of Guidance which is Fully Detailed and does not need any extra explanations.
But you take a group of books as books of guidance, one from Allah and the other from different Imams.
1)-----Brother, Allah commands the momineen in His Exalted Quran:
-----"So do not obey the rejectors and do Jihadan Kabeera (Great Jihad) against them with This (Quran)" (Al Furqaan-52)
In the above Verse, Allah has commanded us to do The Great Jihaad against the kuffaar, with Quran in our hands as the weapon.
It means we have to call the kuffaar of the world to Allah's Quran. That's it.
Whereas the present ummah who follow Al-Bukhari, believe that they should wage a war against the kuffaar to spread Islam.
Brother, how can I go against my Allah when He orders me to do Great Jihaad with Al-Quran in our hands?---How can I kill the non-muslims to spread Islam?
The very meaning of Isalm is to Submit yourself before Allah,----and Salam, Peace, Security.
How can I call the kuffaar to Peace, Salam by waging a war against them and killing and destroyiing them?
Brother, I can not do war, I will only call the kuffaar to Allah.
This is my Iman in my Allah.
2)-----Allah in His Exalted Quran declares that if anyone wants to go out of Islam and become a kafir again, He have no objection in this worldly life. He will question him on The Judgement Day. In this worldly life, Allah Wills to give him a chance before his last breath to return back to Islam.
But Imam Bukhari claims that the Prophet ordered to kill the apostate (Murtad). And whole of the Ummah today have Iman in Imam Bukhari, and not in Allah.
Brother, I will never kill a murtad, at all.
How can I become an enemy of my Allah, and go against His clear-cut Judgement that He Wills to give the murtad a chance to return to Islam.
3)-----The person who commits blasphemy against the Prophet, Allah advices the Prophet to keep patience, and promises that He Himself will look into the affair.
But Imam Bukhari claims that the Prophet ordered to kill the blasphemer.
Brother, I can never go against my Allah's advice, and I would never kill a blasphemer.
I will only try to convince him of Islam. Maybe he will weep, repent and ask Allah's Forgiveness.
This is my Iman in Allah.
Allah declares in His Exalted Quran that there will be no Shafa'ut for the criminals and sinners.
But-----Imam Bukhari claims that the Prophet declares that he will do Shafa'ut for the sinners of his ummah and save them from hellfire.
Brother, I can never have Iman in such a fabricated story of Shafa'ut from the Prophet.
More according to Allah's Quran:
I will never stone the zani to death. Because my Allah never commands us to do so.
I will never degrade womn and take her second in grade with respect to men. Because my Allah never says so.
I will never accept Isa the Messenger alive and returning back to earth. Because my Allah never says so.
-----and so on and on and on-------
Brother this is my Iman in Allah that I find no one in between me and my Allah. No Imam Bukhari, no names of Sahaba, no suffees, no scholars, no mufassir, etc.
Brother, it very clearly means that you worship and serve your Allah,---and I worship and serve my Allah.
And you obey your Prophet,---and I obey my Prophet.
And you follow your Allah's Quran,---and I follow my Allah's Quran.
And a very important point in all this is,---that we two differ with each other.
So, it is very very clear, like daylight, that our Ilah, our Prophets, our Qurans, and our Judgement Days,----are different from each other.
=====================================
One more point is that it is the Ulama Karam of this ummah who have fabricated all these non-Quranic philosophies.
In all times, whenever Allah sent His Messengers, these were the misguided Ulama Karam of the people who always opposed the Messengers.
The unjust rulers of all times persecuted their people, and the misguided ulama always supported those cruel rulers, and they all fought the Messengers of Allah.
Allah annihilated those rulers, ulama and the stubborn people who followed them.
Even today, the Salafee Ulama will invite you to become a Salafee.---The Sunni Ulama will try to make you a Sunni. The Shia Ulama will make you a Shia.
But Allah Wills to make you a momin and a muslim.
So, be warned!
The so-called ahadith in Sahih Al-Bukhari and the likes, in which you have Iman,---you never heard with your own ears the Prophet saying all this.
This is one of the Ulama Karam, Mr. Imam Bukhari who claims that the Prophet said all this.
Brother!---Please don't be angry.
I am not your enemy. And you are not my enemy.
I just put my views before you.
I have Iman that my Allah is Perfect, and His Holy and Exalted Book is Perfect, Complete and Fully Detailed.
It is the ummah's own stubbornness and blindness, that they can't find what Allah is giving them in His Easy-to-understand Book of Hidayah.
What is Iman in Allah?
Iman in Allah is the trust in Allah. Full confidence in Allah---that only Allah is our everything.
There is no partner of Allah.---So, there is no partner of Allah's Quran.
=================================================
Don't say people don't understand.-----People understand everything, at least, when Allah's Revealed Truth is put before them.
Yet, even after understanding Allah's Verses well, they find it difficult to accept The Truth, The Only Truth in the universe.---Why?
Just close your eyes, and peep into your heart. You will find the criminal there.
-----The "Ego".-----Kick him out!
Salam,
ReplyDeleteLately I have been having problems with a sunni friend, you conclusion to this blog gives the answer. It is the "Ego". When ayaats of Allah are put forth, he chose to follow his scholars. Because Allah said to obey the messenger and his scholars obey the words attributed to the messengers !!!! Beyond rationality !!!
PEACE
------------- Student of Allah
I am with you.
ReplyDelete